According to a BBC story, Dr. Sotaro Kita has gotten some intriguing results using Sylvester the cat:
Speakers of different languages not only describe the world differently – they think about it differently too, according to the study.
Dr Sotaro Kita of the University of Bristol’s Department of Experimental Psychology, showed the cartoon to a group of native English, Japanese and Turkish speakers.
He then noted their gestures as they described the action they had seen, finding that speakers of different languages used different gestures to depict the same event.
This appeared to reflect the way the structure of their languages expressed that event.
For example, when describing a scene where Sylvester swings on a rope, the English speakers used gestures showing an arc.
The Japanese and Turkish speakers tended to use straight gestures showing the motion but not the arc.
Dr Kita suggests this is because Japanese and Turkish have no verb that corresponds to the English intransitive verb ‘to swing’.
English speakers use the arc gesture as their language readily expresses the change of location and the arc-shaped trajectory.
But Japanese and Turkish speakers cannot as easily express the concept of movement with an arc trajectory, so they use the straight gesture, Dr Kita argues.
He adds that these differences can be explained by linguistic differences.
Dr Kita said: “My research suggests that speakers of different languages generate different spatial images of the same event in a way that matches the expressive possibilities of their particular language.
“In other words, language influences spatial thinking at the moment of speaking.”
The results are probably overstated, but it’s an interesting line of study. (Thanks to Des for the link.)
Speak Your Mind